Michigan Court orders resentencing for 18 year olds serving LWOP

Heidi • January 24, 2024

Decision impacts 264 persons sentenced to LWOP at age 18

The Michigan Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that 264 incarcerated persons sentenced to life without parole when they were 18 years old must have a new chance to argue for a reduced sentence, if not for freedom. In Michigan v. Poole, a 2-1 appeals court panel held that a 2022 decision that struck down life without parole sentences for 18-year-olds also applies retroactively.


In 2022, the Michigan Supreme Court in People v. Taylor held that sentences of automatic life without parole for 18-year olds violate the state constitution. Because of “diminished culpability and increased prospects for reform,” the court explained at the time, children cannot receive life without parole sentences unless the prosecution proves otherwise by clear and convincing evidence. The 2022 decision however left unanswered the question of whether the decision applied to people who were convicted of murder and were already serving life without parole sentences.


“No 18-year old, regardless of whether they were sentenced in 1990 or 2000 or 2010 or 2023 or ’24 should be serving an unconstitutional penalty, an unconstitutional sentence like mandatory life without parole,” Maya Menlo, an attorney with the State Appellate Defender Office, told Michigan Public Radio.


The decision affecting juveniles sentenced to life without parole sentences dates back to a 2012 U.S. Supreme Court decision, Miller v. Alabama, that ruled a mandatory life sentence for youth ages 17 or younger convicted of first-degree murder was a form of cruel and unusual punishment because youth are less culpable and have greater capacity for rehabilitation. A later U.S. Supreme Court decision, Montgomery v. Louisiana, found those protections to apply retroactively to all youth 17 and under who'd received mandatory life without parole.


Over the years, those decisions have led to multiple resentencing hearings where those factors are considered, as well as additional challenges at the state and federal levels successfully seeking to expand the federal ruling, including the 2022 Michigan Supreme Court decision.


Included in the 2022 Michigan Supreme Court decision;


"Life sentences for children run counter to “a clear national trend toward treating juveniles less harshly than adults and extending Miller beyond just the mandatory LWOP context” and they fail to advance rehabilitative goals, as children sentenced to life are given less access to vital educational and rehabilitative programs. Additionally, whether a child sentenced to life will be paroled often has more to do with politics than the child’s maturity and rehabilitation. A person’s meaningful opportunity to gain release is supposed to be measured in terms of their “demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation,” the court wrote, but is instead subject to “the whims of an executive branch policy directive instructing the Parole Board to forgo consideration of all offenders serving parolable life.”


You can read the full decision from the Michigan Court of Appeals -->> Michigan v. Poole

Illustration: Gabriel Hongsdusit/CalMatters
By Heidi August 1, 2025
Featured in CalMatters is the case of Nathan Gould in context of SB 672, would allow Californians sentenced to LWOP that occurred at age 25 years or younger chance to go before the Parole Board after serving 25 years of their sentence.
State of Texas with handcuffs
By Heidi July 31, 2025
"Texas Hold'em: How the Prison System Keeps its Grip on Parole-Eligible People" is written by Kwaneta Harris, and appears on her Substack page, Write or Die.
Charles McCrory (Photo: Alabama Department of Correctios)
By Heidi July 29, 2025
In 1985, Charles McCrory was wrongly convicted for the murder of his wife in Alabama with “bite mark” evidence, now considered junk science and a leading contributor of wrongful convictions.
Robert Roberson in a phone interview (Photo: Gideon Rogers/Texas Public Radio)
By Heidi July 28, 2025
Robert Roberson is entitled to a new trial, as the Texas-planned State-sponsored murder of a man many believe to be innocent is the furthest thing from justice.
illustration of an open boksyl
By Heidi July 26, 2025
"From Brilliant Mind to Broken Prison System: My Journey Through Incarceration, Re-entry, and Redemption" is written by formerly incarcerated writer Anthony McCarary
The former Dozier School for Boys campus in Marianna, FL (Alicia Vera/The Marshall Project)
By Heidi July 25, 2025
An investigative report from The Marshall Project found at least 50 boys who stayed at two different abusive reform schools in Florida ended up on death row.
Jimmie Duncan and his girlfriend Zoe (Photo: Zoe Grigsby)
By Heidi July 23, 2025
Louisiana prosecutors ask to reinstate Jimmie Duncan's death penalty sentence that was vacated in April 2025 due to a prosecution that relied on junk science.
CCWP hosts a 30 year anniversary event with author Dr. Angela Davis 11/5/2025 5p-8p PT In Oakland CA
By Heidi July 21, 2025
California Coalition for Women's Prisoners hosts an event celebrating 30 years of organizing across the walls of women’s prisons with Dr. Angela Davis on 11/5/2025
STOP Secret Police - Add your support for SB 627 and encourage your CA legislator to do the same.
By Heidi July 18, 2025
Masked law enforcement bring chaos to our communities. CA legislators are taking action: SB 627 bans all law enforcement from covering their faces when policing our neighborhoods.
Officers at the US penitentiary in Thomson, IL use a four-point restraint (US Attorney, N. Illinois)
By Heidi July 17, 2025
US DOJ's Office of the Inspector General (OIG) report is critical of the federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) use of restraints on prisoners, noting officials violated their own rules.
Show More