Michigan Court orders resentencing for 18 year olds serving LWOP

Heidi • January 24, 2024

Decision impacts 264 persons sentenced to LWOP at age 18

The Michigan Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that 264 incarcerated persons sentenced to life without parole when they were 18 years old must have a new chance to argue for a reduced sentence, if not for freedom. In Michigan v. Poole, a 2-1 appeals court panel held that a 2022 decision that struck down life without parole sentences for 18-year-olds also applies retroactively.


In 2022, the Michigan Supreme Court in People v. Taylor held that sentences of automatic life without parole for 18-year olds violate the state constitution. Because of “diminished culpability and increased prospects for reform,” the court explained at the time, children cannot receive life without parole sentences unless the prosecution proves otherwise by clear and convincing evidence. The 2022 decision however left unanswered the question of whether the decision applied to people who were convicted of murder and were already serving life without parole sentences.


“No 18-year old, regardless of whether they were sentenced in 1990 or 2000 or 2010 or 2023 or ’24 should be serving an unconstitutional penalty, an unconstitutional sentence like mandatory life without parole,” Maya Menlo, an attorney with the State Appellate Defender Office, told Michigan Public Radio.


The decision affecting juveniles sentenced to life without parole sentences dates back to a 2012 U.S. Supreme Court decision, Miller v. Alabama, that ruled a mandatory life sentence for youth ages 17 or younger convicted of first-degree murder was a form of cruel and unusual punishment because youth are less culpable and have greater capacity for rehabilitation. A later U.S. Supreme Court decision, Montgomery v. Louisiana, found those protections to apply retroactively to all youth 17 and under who'd received mandatory life without parole.


Over the years, those decisions have led to multiple resentencing hearings where those factors are considered, as well as additional challenges at the state and federal levels successfully seeking to expand the federal ruling, including the 2022 Michigan Supreme Court decision.


Included in the 2022 Michigan Supreme Court decision;


"Life sentences for children run counter to “a clear national trend toward treating juveniles less harshly than adults and extending Miller beyond just the mandatory LWOP context” and they fail to advance rehabilitative goals, as children sentenced to life are given less access to vital educational and rehabilitative programs. Additionally, whether a child sentenced to life will be paroled often has more to do with politics than the child’s maturity and rehabilitation. A person’s meaningful opportunity to gain release is supposed to be measured in terms of their “demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation,” the court wrote, but is instead subject to “the whims of an executive branch policy directive instructing the Parole Board to forgo consideration of all offenders serving parolable life.”


You can read the full decision from the Michigan Court of Appeals -->> Michigan v. Poole

Defendant's seating in San Diego Courtroom (Photo: Adriana Heldiz/CalMatters)
By Heidi June 16, 2025
Signed in 2023, SB97 set to remove a number of significant barriers to overturning wrongful convictions in California. Two years later, Cal Matters reports a lack of defense investigators leaves California unable to provide those promised safeguards.
on sat 6/14, LA Free Legal Clinics will be on the ground to support participants of the LA Protests
By Heidi June 13, 2025
For tomorrow, Saturday June 14th, the free legal clinics offered the second Saturday of every month in Los Angeles will be moved to the streets to support people participating in the Los Angeles protests, as well as people most threatened by the ongoing ICE raids.
Flyer: PEN America calls for mentors for Prison Writing Mentorship Program; apply by 7/31/2025
By Heidi June 12, 2025
PEN America’s Prison & Justice Writing Program is now accepting volunteer applications for the 2025–2026 Prison Writing Mentorship Program, which matches an incarcerated writer with a writer on the outside who has volunteered to read and respond to submitted work.
Photo: Black woman participating in a march, holding a Pride flag. (Photo: Innocence Project)
By Heidi June 10, 2025
LGBTQ+ people are overrepresented throughout the criminal legal system, from their high rates of juvenile justice involvement to the long sentences they often receive as adults. Ending mass incarceration and over criminalization a central part of the movement for LGBTQ liberation.
Rally-Stop Deportations, Citizenship for All!  Today, 4pm PT at West Steps of Capitol in Sacramento
By Heidi June 9, 2025
Felony Murder Elimination Project stands with the people of Los Angeles protesting ICE Raids in Los Angeles who are exercising their right to speak out and peacefully protesting . We also stand with communities nationwide in demanding ICE return people to their families and communities, end family separations and stop unjust detentions.
Prisoner at Green Haven Correctional Facility looks out at prison yard (Skip Dickstein/Albany Times)
By Heidi June 6, 2025
"They Wanted to Have Fewer Prisons. Instead, They Got a Prisoner’s Worst Nightmare," appeared in Slate Magazine in May 2025, and is written by Robert Lee Williams, incarcerated in New York State.
Linda Wood & her son Andre hold a photo of Linda's youngest son Tremane (Nick Oxford, Huff Post)
By Heidi June 5, 2025
Oklahoma plans to set an execution date next week for a man who didn't kill anyone. Tremane Wood was sen­tenced to death a 2004 mur­der that his broth­er, Jake Wood, admit­ted com­mit­ting. It's time to take action to prevent a horrible miscarriage of justice from going forward.
graphic: mass incarceration costs American families nearly $350b out of pocket costs each year
By Heidi June 4, 2025
A report titled "We Can’t Afford It: Mass Incarceration and the Family Tax" from advocacy organization Fwd.us is the latest in a long line of arguments to effectively capture the financial toll prisons and jails exact on American families.
Juvenile offenders in a carceral facility, dressed in orange jumpsuits.
By Heidi June 3, 2025
Please join us in supporting SB 672 (Sen. Susan Rubio D22), which would allows persons sentenced to life without parole (LWOP) for crimes committed before age 26 to request a parole hearing after serving at least 25 years in prison.
Graphic; urge your assemblyperson to support AB 1231 - Safer Communities through Opportunities Act
By Heidi June 1, 2025
FMEP asks supporters to contact their Assemblyperson and urge support for AB 1231, the Safer Communities through Opportunities Act, which would allow courts to grant diversion for non-violent, non-sexual felonies, after consultation with both the prosecutor and defendant.
Show More