Blog Post

Minnesota Man Exonerated After 20 Years Wrongfully Convicted

Heidi • Dec 11, 2023

Witness recanted statement in 2004 Minneapolis murder case

A Minneapolis man is free after spending 18 years in prison after a judge vacated his conviction in a high-profile murder case. 


Marvin Haynes walked out of the Minnesota Correctional Facility in Stillwater today after his 2005 conviction for the shooting of a north Minneapolis flower shop employee was vacated. Haynes, who was 16 at the time, claimed he was home sleeping when 55-year-old Harry (Randy) Sherer was killed. Haynes' alibi was supported by family members. 


The Hennepin County Attorney's Office confirms that Hennepin County Judge William Koch signed an order Monday setting aside Haynes' conviction and that Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty agrees that Haynes and his legal team have proved his constitutional rights were violated during the 2005 trial. In a statement following the news of Haynes' release, Moriarty said that the conviction was based almost exclusively on eyewitness identification, with no forensic evidence like DNA, fingerprints or surveillance video to connect Haynes to the crime. 


Additionally, Moriarty's statement said “Nearly 28 percent of exonerations involve eyewitness identification. Doing the right thing sometimes means we must seek to undo the harms of the past, not defend them. And that is what we have tried to do today. It is not easy to admit and correct our wrongs. But it is necessary,


The vacating of Haynes' murder conviction came after a November 28th hearing. during which his legal team with the Great North Innocence Project raised a number of challenges to the murder conviction, among them that the suspect lineups used to convict were constitutionally defective. Haynes' legal team maintains that the original trial relied on "false evidence" from witnesses and "constitutionally defective eyewitness identification evidence." Haynes' attorneys claim that important eyewitness testimony in the case "should have been suppressed because it was the result of highly suggestive identification techniques and was wholly unreliable."


Andrew Markquart, Haynes' attorney, said his team was "thrilled" watching him leave Stillwater. He said they're introducing new legislation in an effort to prevent the same outcome in similar cases. He also added that the defense team will explore compensatory options for Hayne's wrongful conviction and incarceration, but said at this point they're "taking one step at a time."


"He is a man who has every right in the world to be bitter, but he’s not," Markquart said. "I can’t wait to see what this next chapter of your life has in store for you."


“I just want to thank everybody that supported me through this whole journey. And how ya’ll can recognize that I’m actually innocent,” Haynes said. “I’m just happy that I can correct my narrative. That’s it. I’m so happy.”


You can visit Justice for Marvin Haynes to read more about his story.

From 2016; Death Row cellblock at San Quentin State Prison (Photo: Associated Press)
By Heidi 13 May, 2024
"I am serving a life sentence at San Quentin. I know budget cuts will hurt foster youth," is a commentary piece featured in the San Diego Union-Tribune last week and written by Donald Thompson, who is is serving a life sentence at San Quentin Rehabilitation Center (formerly known as San Quentin State Prison).
Flyer: Saturday May 10th, free community defender resources at the Ross Snyder Rec Center in LA
By Heidi 10 May, 2024
Tomorrow, Saturday May 10, free community defender resources will be offered at the Ross Snyder Recreation Center in Los Angeles from 10a-12 noon.
Election worker interacts with someone detained in the Denver jail. (Photo: Denver sheriff’s office)
By Heidi 08 May, 2024
Last week, the Colorado legislature adopted Senate Bill 72, a first-in-the-nation reform that requires county sheriffs to better work with county clerks to facilitate voting for eligible voters who are confined pre-trial in jails.
AB 2959 - Prioritize families over profits; CDCR visiting room food prices v.. food store prices
By Heidi 07 May, 2024
AB 2959, introduced by Assemblyperson Liz Ortega (D20), seeks to reduce and regulate food prices in California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation visiting rooms, require CDCR to renew and expand vendor contracts to include healthy options, and offer diverse food choices in prison vending machines.
Graphic - AB 2178 (Ting) provides a structured approach to managing surplus in CA state prisons.
By Heidi 06 May, 2024
AB 2178 promotes a more efficient and cost-effective use of taxpayer money by eliminating surplus bed capacity, potentially saving billions and paving the way for closing prisons. Please help us advocate for his bill ahead of hearing in the CA Assembly Appropriations Committee.
By Heidi 02 May, 2024
"California’s budget deficit will force difficult cuts. This one should be the easiest," an opinion piece written by Assemblyperson Phil Ting and CURB Executive Director Amber Rose Howard for the LA Times, advocates for closing and consolidating prison space at a time when prison bed occupancy is already decreasing.
Image of police engaged in arrest in a 2020 Hong Kong protest (Photo: Sandra Sanders/Shutterstock)
By Heidi 30 Apr, 2024
The myth of “superhuman strength;" a descriptor often applied to Black people in police use-of-force cases, dates back to Reconstruction. When “superhuman strength” is allowed as a use-of-force justification in court cases, dehumanizing misconceptions and stereotypes make their way into the wider criminal justice system.
Graphic - Ending girls' incarceration in California is possible
By Heidi 29 Apr, 2024
The Vera Institute of Justice and Young Women’s Freedom Center released ‘Freedom and Justice: Ending the Incarceration of Girls and Gender-Expansive Youth in California,' an in-depth look at the incarceration of girls and gender-expansive youth in California and steps to end their incarceration.
Illustration of a man lifting weights against a bright yellow backdrop (Illustration - Graham Sisk)
By Heidi 26 Apr, 2024
The essay "How I Regained My Self-Esteem in Prison" by Kashawn Taylor, an incarcerated writer in Connecticut, appears on the website for the Prison Journalism Project.
Shelby Hoffman discusses her
By Heidi 25 Apr, 2024
In Florida, and most other states, incarcerated persons are charged for the costs of their time in prison. The practice, called "pay-to-stay," leaves many former offenders with staggering debt.
Show More
Share by: