What is 4th of July to Incarcerated People?

Heidi • July 10, 2025

The essay "What, to the American Incarcerated Person, Is Your Fourth of July?" appeared in The Marshall Project, as part of the Life Inside series, stories as told from first-person essays from people who live or work in the criminal justice system.


Excerpts from the essay appear below.


*****


On July 5, 1852, the formerly enslaved abolitionist Frederick Douglass delivered his scathing Independence Day speech about the paradox of patriotism in an America that had passed its second federal Fugitive Slave Act. This notorious 1850 legislation required law enforcement to arrest people they suspected of escaping slavery, on even the thinnest of evidence. It also made feeding and sheltering runaways a crime punishable by six months in prison and a $1,000 fine.


After praising the “the truly great” and “brave” signers of the Declaration of Independence, Douglass asked his Rochester, New York, audience one of the most memorable rhetorical questions in U.S. history: "What, to the American Slave, is your Fourth of July?"


Inspired by Douglass’ famous question, 20 people ensnared in this country’s sprawling criminal legal system answered this variation of it: “What, to the currently or formerly incarcerated American, is your Fourth of July?”



  • Jeremy Zielinski, 41 - Woodbourne Correctional Facility, Woodbourne, New York: America has one of the highest incarceration rates on Earth. Still, nothing brings liberty to mind like hearing fireworks from behind a 30-foot wall. Are America’s prisons corrupt, oppressive and exploitative? Of course. But I celebrate because I can. I know that independence isn’t a historical event, but principled defiance. It’s the power of a mind that recognizes its own freedom from external control. If tyranny is a boot on the neck of a nation, liberation is using your last breath to laugh at the person wearing it.


  • Jonathan Vargas, 37 - Ohio State Penitentiary, Youngstown, Ohio: My first response: My Independence Day will come when I’m released from prison. But when I look deeper into myself, I can say that it came the day I stopped beating myself up, forgave myself, and became the man I always wanted to be. Regardless of whether I’m in prison, I can still be free in my mind, in my heart and in my soul.


*****


You can read the full essay, "What, to the American Incarcerated Person, Is Your Fourth of July?" at the Marshall Project website. The Marshall Project is a nonpartisan, nonprofit news organization that seeks to create and sustain a sense of national urgency about the U.S. criminal justice system, working to impact the system through journalism, rendering it more fair, effective, transparent and humane.


If you or someone you know is interested in submitting to the Life Inside series, The Marshall Project is looking for 1,000 to 1,400-word nonfiction pieces about a personal experience with the system. They want slices of life rather than full autobiographies. Focus on telling a good story — one that is vivid, surprising, instructive or enlightening to a reader who may not share your frame of reference.

Incarcerated firefighters during January LA Wildfires (Photo: AP Newswire)
By Heidi July 9, 2025
Following years of advocacy, California will start paying incarcerated firefighters federal minimum wage of $7.25/hour during active emergencies starting Jan 1st.
Doorplate for Great North Innocence Project in Minneapolis, MN (Photo: WCCO TV/CBS News Minnesota)
By Heidi July 7, 2025
Innocence Project asks supporters to urge elected representatives to robustly fund & protect Federal innocence and forensic science programs in FY26 spending bills 
an adult hand grasping a child's hand through prison bars - Photo: iStock
By Heidi July 1, 2025
In May 2025 the Incarcerated Womxn’s Clemency and Support Project (IWCSP) and Kwaneta Harris Defense Campaign hosted a webinar entitled “Mothering Behind Bars: Voices of Incarcerated Mothers in Reflection of Mother’s Day.
Aerial of Salinas Valley State Prison in Soledad, CA (Photo: KSBW News)
By Heidi June 27, 2025
Incarcerated people at Salinas Valley State Prison in CA declared a hunger strike, protesting alleged are unlawful practices by California Department of Corrections.
image of State of California capitol building in Sacramento next to the California state flag.
By Heidi June 26, 2025
Legislative update on SB 672, Youth Rehabilitation and Opportunity Act, (Sen. Susan Rubio) which would allow some juvenile LWOP convictions to seek parole board hearing.
Leonard Peltier, at his home on the Chippewa Reservation in North Dakota (Kerem Yücel/MPR News)
By Heidi June 25, 2025
After 50 years wrongfully imprisoned, Indigenous activist Leonard Peltier is home. MPR News sits with Peltier in one of his first longform interview since his release.
ICE agents outside a Newark NJ detention facility (Photo:  Brian Branch Price/ZUMA Press Wire)
By Heidi June 24, 2025
Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is detaining an increasing number of immigrants without any criminal history, according to recent federal government data.
Join civil rights leaders to urge Gov. Newsom to commute all death sentences; rally at capital 6-26
By Heidi June 20, 2025
Clemency California invites all clemency advocates to the capital in Sacramento on Thursday, June 26th, starting at 10am, to help call on California Governor Gavin Newsom to commute all California death sentences.
fingers forming heart hands from behind prison bars (Photo: Rajesh Rajput)
By Heidi June 20, 2025
The essay "Benjamin Case and the Power of Love" appears at the Prison Writers website, and is written by Benjamin Case, incarcerated in South Carolina.
graphic of a public defender in a courtroom (graphic - iStock)
By Heidi June 17, 2025
Public defenders are crucial to ensuring a fair justice system for all by providing legal representation to those who cannot afford it. After a Mississippi court ordered state legislators better fund public defenders after significant delays in providing representation, the program is set to receive funding.
Show More