Debunking Myths of Improved Public Safety with Law Enforcement

Heidi • February 20, 2024

Study from Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice examines crime clearance rates in CA

In response to the largely conservative media-driven drumbeat about crime waves taking over America's cities, violent crime rates have dropped significantly since 2020, a year when the COVID pandemic brought about a significant increase in crime.


"At some point in 2022 — at the end of 2022 or through 2023 — there was just a tipping point where violence started to fall and it just continued to fall," said Jeff Asher, a crime analyst and co-founder of AH Datalytics.


A report published this weekend in the San Francisco Chronicle offers California's entry into the discussion. Despite the drumbeat, again, largely from conservative voices that the "Defund" movement (that never happened) was responsible for the increase in violent crime (that also didn't happen), those voices claimed that robust law enforcement was the key to improving public safety.


A new report from Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice that examined crime clearance rates -  key indicator of how well police are doing their jobs - for California between 1990 and 2022, indicates that increased spending on law enforcement does not improve public safety. Not recently, and not for decades.


By the numbers:


  • During the past three decades, the percentage of reported violent and property crimes solved by police through an arrest dropped a whopping 41%. During the same three decades, the amount California taxpayers spend to fund law enforcement has risen by a staggering 52%. 
  • Over the last 30 years, the number of reported crimes to police has plunged about 50%, yet crime clearance rates in San Francisco (6.7%) and Alameda (5.8%) Counties - home to some of the state’s loudest calls for more cops and more police funding - are some of the worst performing jurisdictions in California.


Clearly, the overperformance can't be blamed on being swamped, considering the documented decrease in reported crimes. Why are crime clearance rates so bad, especially considering police spending in 1990 was $427 per California resident, then that amount ballooned to $651 in 2022? This amounts to an historic $25.5 billion in spending by the entire state in police funding, and all California residents got for that increase was abysmal crime clearance rates.


Yet, again, despite the decreased crime rates, someone arrested by police in California for a violent crime or property crime is three times more likely to be imprisoned than they were in 1990. The rate jumped 207% over three decades. Additionally, in 2022, the imprisonment rates for property offenses in California were 26% higher than they were in 2014 when Proposition 47 was passed, which raised the felony threshold for theft from $400 to $950.


Despite California’s supposedly liberal mindset, billions get spent on law enforcement while programs with proven track records aimed at addressing the root causes of crime, poverty, homelessness, inequitable education access, have shoestring budgets. 


Don't buy the myth that California is soft on crime. It's not true.


Don't buy the myth, built on that myth, that increased law enforcement spending is needed to deal with increased crime. That's not true either.


San Francisco Chronicle --->> "Law-and-order folks need to see this sobering data about law enforcement in California"

Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice study --->> "California Law Enforcement Agencies Are Spending More But Solving Fewer Crimes"

Charles McCrory (Photo: Alabama Department of Correctios)
By Heidi July 29, 2025
In 1985, Charles McCrory was wrongly convicted for the murder of his wife in Alabama with “bite mark” evidence, now considered junk science and a leading contributor of wrongful convictions.
Robert Roberson in a phone interview (Photo: Gideon Rogers/Texas Public Radio)
By Heidi July 28, 2025
Robert Roberson is entitled to a new trial, as the Texas-planned State-sponsored murder of a man many believe to be innocent is the furthest thing from justice.
illustration of an open boksyl
By Heidi July 26, 2025
"From Brilliant Mind to Broken Prison System: My Journey Through Incarceration, Re-entry, and Redemption" is written by formerly incarcerated writer Anthony McCarary
The former Dozier School for Boys campus in Marianna, FL (Alicia Vera/The Marshall Project)
By Heidi July 25, 2025
An investigative report from The Marshall Project found at least 50 boys who stayed at two different abusive reform schools in Florida ended up on death row.
Jimmie Duncan and his girlfriend Zoe (Photo: Zoe Grigsby)
By Heidi July 23, 2025
Louisiana prosecutors ask to reinstate Jimmie Duncan's death penalty sentence that was vacated in April 2025 due to a prosecution that relied on junk science.
CCWP hosts a 30 year anniversary event with author Dr. Angela Davis 11/5/2025 5p-8p PT In Oakland CA
By Heidi July 21, 2025
California Coalition for Women's Prisoners hosts an event celebrating 30 years of organizing across the walls of women’s prisons with Dr. Angela Davis on 11/5/2025
STOP Secret Police - Add your support for SB 627 and encourage your CA legislator to do the same.
By Heidi July 18, 2025
Masked law enforcement bring chaos to our communities. CA legislators are taking action: SB 627 bans all law enforcement from covering their faces when policing our neighborhoods.
Officers at the US penitentiary in Thomson, IL use a four-point restraint (US Attorney, N. Illinois)
By Heidi July 17, 2025
US DOJ's Office of the Inspector General (OIG) report is critical of the federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) use of restraints on prisoners, noting officials violated their own rules.
Ella Baker Center Virtual Mail Night is Monday 7/21 530p-730p PT. Register: bit.ly/MAILNIGHT721
By Heidi July 16, 2025
Ella Baker Center hosts a virtual mail night where attendees respond to letters from incarcerated people. The next event is Monday July 21st,530p-730p PT.
Charles Collins (left), and Brian Boles (right) in a New York City Courtroom (Steven Hirsch/New York
By Heidi July 15, 2025
Brian Boles and Charles Collins were exonerated for a 1994 murder after new DNA testing made it impossible to uphold their convictions in New York City.
Show More